  batunaev-ev-vestnik-2021-4-ru.pdf |
- 7
- The genesis of the Mongolian revolution of 1921: methodological and theoretical aspects
- Batunaev E.V. The genesis of the Mongolian revolution of 1921: methodological and theoretical aspects. Vestnik of Kostroma State University, 2021, vol. 27, № 4, pp. 47-55 (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.34216/1998-0817-2021-27-4-47-55
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.34216/1998-0817-2021-27-4-47-55
- УДК: 94(517.3)”1921”
- Publish date: 2021-11-15
- Annotation: The article examines the problematic and key issues of Russian historiography, theoretical and methodological aspects of the Mongolian revolution of 1921. Topicality of the study is due to the fact that the current scientific discourse pays great attention to the study of revolutionary processes in a broader historical context, with the involvement of new methodological approaches, previously unexplored materials. The Mongolian revolution of 1921 became a turning point on the path of the socialist reorganisation of the traditional nomadic society, carrying out radical political, socio-economic changes within the framework of the young Mongolian state. Particular attention is paid to the evolution of views in Russian, Mongolian and Western historiography, historical approaches, methodology in the study of the problem under consideration, new controversial aspects of the problems of the political history of Mongolia and Russian (Soviet)-Mongolian relations are revealed. The novelty of the research is seen in the fact that the analysis of historical literature showed that the Mongolian Revolution of 1921 in transnational history was a complex and multifactorial phenomenon that included both internal and external factors: the movement of the Mongols themselves towards independence and sovereignty, the advancement of revolutionary ideas Comintern in the East, ensuring the security of the eastern borders from the USSR. The author comes to the conclusion that the Mongolian Revolution of 1921 became a large-scale event in its entire centuries-old history, led to colossal changes in the political, economic, social and cultural life of Mongolian society.
- Keywords: Mongolian revolution of 1921, Soviet-Mongol agreement of 1921, Comintern, Mongolian People's Party, Mongolian People's Revolutionary Army, political programme, historiography.
- Funding and acknowledgments: The work was carried out within the framework of a state assignment, project “Historical space of the Mongolian world: archaeological cultures, societies and states”, № 121031000241-1
- Literature list: Bazarov B.V. Neizvestnoe iz istorii panmongolizma [Unknown from the history of Pan-Mongolism]. Ulan-Ude, BNC SO RAN Publ., 2002, 67 p. (In Russ.) Batbajar Ts. Mongoliia i Iaponiia v pervoi polovine XX veka [Mongolia and Japan in the first half of the XX century]. Ulan-Ude, IPK VSGAKI Publ., 229 p. (In Russ.) Belov E.A. Rossiia i Mongoliia (1911-1919) [Russia and Mongolia (1911-1919)]. Moscow, Institut vostokovedenija Publ., 1999, 238 p. (In Russ.) Golman M.I. Problemy noveishei istorii MNR v burzhuaznoi istoriografii SShA [Problems of the modern history of the Mongolian People's Republic in the bourgeois historiography of the United States]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1970, 178 p. (In Russ.) Graivoronskiy V.V. O novykh podkhodakh k izucheniiu rossiisko-mongol'skikh otnoshenii v XX veke [On new approaches to the study of Russian-Mongolian relations in the XX century]. Rossiia i Mongoliia: novyi vzgliad na istoriiu vzaimootnoshenii v XX veke [Russia and Mongolia: a new look at the history of relations in the XX century]. Moscow, 2001, pp. 8–16. (In Russ.) Dashdavaa Ch. K voprosu o kharaktere Mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 goda [On the nature of the Mongolian revolution of 1921]. Rossiia i Mongoliia: novyi vzgliad na istoriiu vzaimootnoshenii v XX veke [Russia and Mongolia: a new look at history (diplomacy, economics, culture)]. Irkutsk, 2015, pp. 60–62. (In Russ.) Zhabaeva L.B. Elbek-Dorzhi Rinchino i natsional'no-demokraticheskoe dvizhenie mongol'skikh narodov [Elbek-Dorzhi Rinchino and the National Democratic Movement of the Mongolian Peoples]. Ulan-Ude, VSGTU Publ., 2000, 334 p. (In Russ.) Zheleznyakov A.S. Rozhdenie mongol'skogo kommunizma: 1920 god [The birth of Mongolian communism: 1920]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta [Moscow State University Bulletin], 2000, № 1, pp. 46–63. (In Russ.) Ivanenko V.I. Gody, ravnye vekam: K 60-letiiu MNR: k shestidesiatiletiiu Mong. Narodn. Revoliutsii [Years equal to centuries: To the 60th anniversary of the Mongolian People's Republic]. Moscow, Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija Publ., 1981, 160 p. (In Russ.) Istoriia Mongolii: Vek XX [History of Mongolia XX century]: monograph; resp. ed. G.S. Yaskina. Moscow, Institut vostokovedenija RAS Publ., 2007, 448 p. (In Russ.) Kallinikov A. Natsional'no-revoliutsionnoe dvizhenie v Mongolii [National Revolutionary Movement in Mongolia]. Moscow, Leningrad, Moskovskij rabochij Publ., 1926, 120 p. (In Russ.) Kuzmin Yu.V. Mongol'skie istoriki ob antifeodal'nykh preobrazovaniiakh v MNR na demokraticheskom etape revoliutsii 1921-1940 gg. [Mongolian historians on antifeudal transformations in the Mongolian People's Republic at the democratic stage of the 1921-1940 revolution]. Vestnik LSU [Leningrad State University Bulletin], 1983, № 20, pp. 25–30. (In Russ.) Kuzmin Yu.V., Sukhodolov A.P., Boldbaatar B. Rossiisko-mongol'skie otnosheniia v nachale XX veka (1900-1921 gg.) [Russian-Mongolian relations at the beginning of the 20th century (1900-1921)]. Bjuleten' irkutskoj gosudarstvennoj jekonomicheskoj akademii [Bulletin of the Irkutsk State Economic Academy], 2013, № 6, pp. 92–99. (In Russ.) Kuras L.V., Norovsambuu H., Tsybenov B.D. Otto Ivanovich Makstenek: u istokov Mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 g. [Otto Ivanovich Maksteneck: At the Origins of the Mongolian Revolution of 1921]. Oriental Studies, 2020, vol. 13, № 2, pp. 305–317. (In Russ.) Kuras L.V, Tsybenov B.D. 90 let Mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 g. [90 years of the Mongolian revolution of 1921]. Ulaanbaatar, Bambi-San hevlelyin gazar. Publ., 2011. Vestnik BNC SO RAN [Bulletin of BNTS SO RAS], 2011, № 4, pp. 235–238. (In Russ.) Kuras L.V., Tsybenov B.D. Dal'nevostochnaia respublika: ot konspirativnoi kvartiry do «kolybeli» Mongol'skoi revoliutsii [Far Eastern Republic: from a safe house to the ‟cradle” of the Mongolian revolution]. Rossija i ATR [Russia and ATR], 2021, № 1 (111), pp. 194–208. (In Russ.) Luzyanin S.G. Rossiia-Mongoliia-Kitai v pervoi polovine XX v.: Politicheskie vzaimootnosheniia v 1911-1946 gg. [Russia-Mongolia-China in the first half of the twentieth century: Political relations in 1911-1946]. Moscow, Ogni Publ., 2003, 319 p. (In Russ.) Mikhalev A.V. Mongol'skaia revoliutsiia 1921 v sovetskoi istoriografii [The Mongolian Revolution of 1921 in Soviet historiography]. Ulan-Ude Izdatel'stvo BGU Publ., 2006, 129 p. (In Russ.) Maisky I.M. Mongoliia nakanune revoliutsii [Mongolia on the eve of the revolution]. Moscow, Vostochnaja literature Publ., 1959, 310 p. (In Russ.) Mongoliia v dokumentakh Kominterna (1919-1934). [Mongolia in the documents of the Comintern (1919-1934)], ed. B.V. Bazarov. Ulan-Ude, BNC SO RAN Publ., 2012, part 1: Scientific, 527 p. (In Russ.) Mongoliia v dokumentakh Kominterna (1919-1934) [Mongolia in the documents of the Comintern (1929-1934)], ed. B.V. Bazarov. Ulan-Ude, BNC SO RAN Publ., 2012, part 2: Scientific, 480 p. (In Russ.) Mongoliia v dokumentakh iz arkhivov FSB Rossii (1922–1936 gg.) [Mongolia in documents from the archives of the FSB of Russia (1922–1936)]: (Collection of documents); sci. ed. V.V. Naumkin, otv. ed. K.V. Orlova, V.V. Grayvoronsky. Moscow, IV RAN Publ., 2019, 528 p. (In Russ.) Ocherki istorii Mongol'skoi narodno-revoliutsionnoi partii [Essays on the history of the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party]. Moscow, Politizdat Publ., 1971, 346 p. (In Russ.) Revoliutsionnye meropriiatiia narodnogo pravitel'stva Mongolii v 1921-1924 gg. [Revolutionary measures of the people's government of Mongolia in 1921-1924]. M., Vostochnaja literature Publ., 1960, 212 p. (In Russ.) Rossiisko-Mongol'skoe voennoe sotrudnichestvo (1911-1946) [Russian-Mongolian military cooperation (1911-1946) collection of documents]: in 2 parts. Moscow, Ulan-Ude, FGOU VPO VSGAKI Publ., 2008, part 1, 2008, 349 p. (In Russ.) Rossiisko-Mongol'skoe voennoe sotrudnichestvo (1911-1946) [Russian-Mongolian military cooperation (1911-1946) collection of documents]: in 2 parts. Moscow, Ulan-Ude, FGOU VPO VSGAKI Publ., 2008, part 2, 2008, 326 p. (In Russ.) Roshchin S.K. Politicheskaia istoriia Mongolii (1921-1940 gg.) [Political history of Mongolia (1921-1940)]. Moscow, IV RAN Publ., 1999, 325 p. (In Russ.) Roshchin S.K. Natsional'nye demokraty 20-kh godov o mongol'skom traditsionnom obshchestve i ego evoliutsii [National Democrats of the 1920s on Mongolian Traditional Society and Its Evolution]. Dialogue among Civilizations: Interaction between Nomadic and Other Cultures of Central Asia: International Symposium. Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, August 15-16, 2001, pp. 358-362. (In Russ.) Ulymzhiev D.B. Put' mongol'skogo aratstva k sotsializmu [The path of the Mongol aratism to socialism]. Novosibirsk, Nauka Publ., 1987, 288 p. (In Russ.) Ulymzhiev D.B. Mongol'skaia Narodnaia Respublika stroit sotsializm [The Mongolian People's Republic is building socialism]. Ulan-Ude, Burjatskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo Publ., 1959, 110 p. (In Russ.) Khishigt N. K voprosu o mongolo-rossiiskikh otnosheniiakh perioda mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 goda [On the issue of Mongolian-Russian relations during the Mongolian revolution of 1921]. Problemy istorii i kul'tury kochevykh tsivilizatsii Tsentral'noi Azii [Problems of the history and culture of nomadic civilizations in Central Asia]: mater. int. scientific. conf. Ulan-Ude, 2000, vol. 4: [History. Philosophy. Sociology. Philology], pp. 151–156. (In Russ.) Khishigt N Uchastie Ts. Zhamtsarano v mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 g. [Participation of Ts. Zhamtsarano in the Mongolian revolution of 1921]. Istoriia i kul'tura narodov Tsentral'noi Azii: nasledie i sovremennost' [History and culture of the peoples of Central Asia: heritage and modernity]. Ulan-Ude, BNC SO RAN Publ., 2008, part 1: [History, source studies, historiography, culture and education], pp. 21–25. (In Russ.) Khishigt N. Uchastie Batukhana v Mongol'skoi revoliutsii 1921 goda [Batukhan's participation in the Mongolian revolution of 1921]. Istoriia, istochnikovedenie, istoriografiia, kul'tura i obrazovanie [Russia and Mongolia: a new look at history (diplomacy, economics, culture)]. Irkutsk, 2015, pp. 259–262. (In Russ.) Tsetsegma J. Buriatskaia nauchnaia intelligentsiia v stanovlenii mongol'skogo gosudarstva v pervoi treti XX v. [Buryat scientific intelligentsia in the formation of the Mongolian state in the first third of the XX century]. Ulan-Ude, Izd.-poligraf. kompleks VSGAKI Publ., 2006, 231 p. (In Russ.) Chimitdorzhiev Sh.B. Buriatskie deiateli - uchastniki revoliutsii 1921 g. i demokraticheskikh preobrazovanii v Mongolii [Buryat leaders - participants in the 1921 revolution and democratic reforms in Mongolia. Outstanding Buryat leaders]. Ulan-Ude, Burjatskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo Publ., 2004, issue. 5, pp. 175–182 (In Russ.) Chimitdorzhiev Sh.B. Soglashenie ob ustanovlenii druzhestvennykh otnoshenii (1921 g.) i rossiisko-mongol'skie otnosheniia na rubezhe XX-XXI vv. [Agreement on the establishment of friendly relations (1921) and Russian-Mongolian relations at the turn of the XX-XXI centuries]. Mongolovednye issledovaniia [Mongolian studies]. Ulan-Ude, Institut mongolovedenija buddologii i tebetologii SO RAN Publ., 2003, pp. 6-16. (In Russ.) Choibolsan H Kratkii ocherk istorii mongol'skoi narodnoi revoliutsii [Brief outline of the history of the Mongolian people's revolution]. Moscow, Inostrannaja literature Publ., 1952, 79 p. (In Russ.) Shirendyb B. Istoriia Mongol'skoi narodnoi revoliutsii 1921 goda. [History of the Mongolian People's Revolution of 1921]. Moscow, Nauka, Vostochnaja literatura Publ., 1971, 400 p. (In Russ.) 50 let 1972 - 50 let narodnoi Mongolii: polveka bor'by i truda. [50 years of people's Mongolia: half a century of struggle and labor], ch. ed. Ts. Puntsagnorov. Ulan Bator, Gosudarstvennoe MNR Publ., 1972, 167 p. (In Russ.) Baabar B. Ne zabud'! inache pogibel'! [Do not forget! Otherwise, death]. Ulaanbaatar, 1990, 121 p. (In Mong.) Baabar B. Kochev'e, osedlost' [Nomad, settled, territory]. Ulaanbaatar, 1995, pр. 1, 531 p. (In Mong.) Boldbaatar H. Ministr Amar [Minister Amar]. Ulaanbaatar, 1993, 98 p. (In Mong.) Bat-Ochir L. Choibolsan [Choibolsan]. Ulaanbaatar, 1996, 122 p. (In Mong.) Lhamsuren B. Mongol'skaia vneshniaia sreda i nezavisimost' [External environment and state independence of Mongolia]. Ulaanbaatar, 1995, 121 p. (In Mong.) Khishigt N. Mongol'skaia revoliutsiia 1921 [The Mongolian Revolution: 1921 (A Review of the History of the Cellular Democratic Revolution in Mongolia)]. Ulaanbaatar, Bambi Foundation Publ., 2011, 400 p. (In Mong.) Istoriia Mongolii: 20 vek [History of Mongolia (XX century)]. Ulaanbaatar, 2003, vol. 5, 403 p. (In Mong.)