  babichev-da-vestnik-2020-1.pdf |
- 32
- Legality of decisions taken by the subjects of operational and investigative activities: on the question of the legal nature
- Babichev D.A. Legality of decisions taken by the subjects of operational and investigative activities: on the question of the legal nature. Vestnik of Kostroma State University, 2020, vol. 26, № 1, pp. 204-211 (In Russ.). DOI 10.34216/1998-0817-2020-26-1-204-211
- DOI: 10.34216/1998-0817-2020-26-1-204-211
- УДК: 351.746.2:340.132.83
- Publish date: 2019-11-25
- Annotation: The article deals with the problem of determining the legal nature of the decisions taken by the bodies engaged in operational investigative activities. Stating the amorphousness in the relevant scientific research, the author refers to the doctrinal ideas about the essence of legality in the field of operational and investigative activities. On the basis of a critical analysis of the provisions set forth in the most cited dissertations, monographs, textbooks, as well as in the comments to the Laws of the Russian Federation "On the Prosecutor's office of the Russian Federation", "On operational investigative activities", a number of judgements are put forward. It is stated that the rule of law is a social and legal phenomenon, which can be considered to be a principle, a method or regime. Legality as a phenomenon develops and changes together with society, law and the state. Understanding and interpreting the rule of law often does not take into account the conceptual shifts in the architectonics of legal regulation that have occurred in post-Soviet Russian legislation. The author comes to the conclusion that the modern conditions for the implementation of operational and investigative tasks dictate the urgent need to clarify and even revise the essence of legality by moving from a narrow to a broad understanding of its legal nature. In particular, preference is given to the legal approach, which implies subordination of the rule of law to higher legal principles and ideals, for example, justice.
- Keywords: legality, law, normative legal act, operational-search activity, operational-search decision, legal nature, subject of operational-search activity, justice, legality, crime.
- Literature list: Aleksandrov N.G. Pravo i zakonnost' v period razvernutogo stroitel'stva kommunizma [Law and legality in the period of expanded construction of communism]. Moscow, Gosyurizdat, 1961, 271 p. (In Russ.) Alekseev S.S. Problemy teorii prava [Problems of legal theory]. Moscow, 1997, 400 p. (In Russ.) Alekseev S.S. Obshchie dozvoleniya i zaprety v sovetskom prave [General permissions and prohibitions in Soviet law]. Moscow, YUridicheskaya literatura Publ., 1989, 288 p. (In Russ.) Amirbekov K.I. Transformaciya vzglyadov na ponimanie zakonnosti kak pravovoj kategorii [Transformation of views on the understanding of legality as a legal category]. Rossijskaya yusticiya [Russian justice]. 2016, № 4, pp. 2–5. (In Russ.) But N.D., Lar'kov A.N. Svoboda ekonomicheskoj deyatel'nosti i zakonnost': monografiya [Freedom of economic activity and legality: monograph]. Moscow: YUrlitinform Publ., 2010, 424 p. (In Russ.) Vinokurov A.YU. Prokurorskaya deyatel'nost': 25 let evolyucii [Prosecutorial activity: 25 years of evolution]. Prokuratura: vchera, segodnya, zavtra (Suharevskie chteniya): sb. materialov II Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. [Prosecutor's office: yesterday, today, tomorrow (Sukharev readings): collection of materials of the II International scientific and practical conference] (g. Moskva, 7 oktyabrya 2016 g.), pp. 64–75. (In Russ.) Vinokurov A.YU. Nauchno-prakticheskij kommentarij k Federal'nomu zakonu «O prokurature Rossijskoj Federacii» (postatejnyj) [Scientific and practical commentary on the Federal law “on the Prosecutor's office of the Russian Federationˮ (article by article)]: v 2 t. 3-e izd., pererab. i dop. Moscow, Izdatel'stvo YUrajt Publ., 2018, vol. 1, 359 p. (In Russ.) Guzova A.S. K voprosu o soblyudenii zakonnosti v operativno-rozysknoj deyatel'nosti pri realizacii funkcii prokurorskogo nadzora [On the issue of compliance with the law in operational investigative activities in the implementation of the function of Prosecutor's supervision]. Vestnik KrasGAU [Bulletin Of Krasgau], 2012, № 4, pp. 210–212. URL: file:///C:/Users/Dmitriy/Desktop/k-voprosu-o-soblyudenii-zakonnosti-v-operativno-rozysknoy-deyatelnosti-pri-realizatsii-funktsii-prokurorskogo-nadzora.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 29.10.2019). (In Russ.) Gusev V.A., Lugovik V.F. Teoriya operativno-rozysknyh procedur: monografiya [The theory of operational-investigative procedures: monograph]. Moscow, Prospekt Publ., 2019, 336 p. (In Russ.) Domracheva A.N., Safin H.SH., Fedyaeva G.A. Zakonnost' v deyatel'nosti gosudarstvennyh organov Rossijskoj Federacii i problemy sovershenstvovaniya ponyatiya «zakonnost'» [Legality in the activities of state bodies of the Russian Federation and problems of improving the concept of “legalityˮ]. Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta kooperacii [Bulletin Of the Russian University of cooperation], 2018, № 3, pp. 105–107. (In Russ.) Zaharcev S.I. Operativno-rozysknaya deyatel'nost' v HKHІ veke: monografiya [Operational and investigative activities in the twenty-FIRST century: monograph], S.I. Zaharcev, YU.YU. Ignashchenkov, V.P. Sal'nikov. Moscow , Norma Publ., 2015, 400 p. (In Russ.) Klochkov V.V. Aktual'nye problemy teorii zakonnosti i prokurorskogo nadzora: monografiya [Actual problems of the theory of legality and Prosecutor's supervision: monograph], sost.: A.V. Klochkova, O.V. Pristanskaya; Akad. Gen. prokuratury Ros. Federacii. Moscow, 2012, 262 p. (In Russ.) Kommentarij k Federal'nomu zakonu «Ob operativno-rozysknoj deyatel'nosti»: S prilozheniem reshenij Konstitucionnogo Suda Rossijskoj Federacii i obzorov praktiki Evropejskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka [Comment on the Federal law “on operational search activitiesˮ. With the Appendix of decisions of the constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and reviews of the practice of the European Court of human rights], otv. red. V.S. Ovchinskij, vstup. st. V.D. Zor'kina. 3-e izd., dop. i pererab. Moscow, Norma Publ.: INFRA-M Publ., 2019, 576 p. (In Russ.) Lugovik V.F. Pravovoj status operupolnomochennogo pri provedenii operativno-rozysknyh meropriyatij: monografiya [The legal status of a security officer when carrying out quickly-search actions: monograph], V.F. Lugovik, S.M. Lugovich. Moscow, INFRA-M Publ., 2018, 156 p. (In Russ.) Macyuk V.YA., Panasyuk S.A., Nіkolajchuk V.A. [i dr.] Naukovo-praktichnij komentar Zakonu Ukraїni «Pro operativno-rozshukovu dіyal'nіst'» [Scientific and practical commentary on The law of Ukraine “on operational search activitiesˮ]. Stanom na 01.05.2011 r., za zag. red. Macyuka V.YA. Kiev, Vidavnichij dіm «Profesіonal» Publ., 2011, pp. 304 p. (In Russ.) Osnovy operativno-rozysknoj deyatel'nosti v Ukraine (ponyatie, principy, pravovoe obespechenie): uchebnoe posobie [Fundamentals of operational and investigative activities in Ukraine (the concept, principles, legal regulation): textbook], E.A. Didorenko, B.I. Baranenko, V.A. Glazkov i dr.; pod red. prof. E.V. Vilenskoj; MVD Ukrainy, Lug. akad. vnutr. del im. 10-letiya nezavisimosti Ukrainy Publ. Lugansk, RIO LAVD, 2006, p. 1, 245 p. (In Russ.) Pashin V.M., Babichev D.A. Prokurorskij nadzor za zakonnost'yu operativno-rozysknyh reshenij v zerkale reformirovaniya kontrol'no-nadzornoj deyatel'nosti [Prosecutor's supervision of the legality of operational search decisions in the mirror of control and supervision reform]. Vestnik Rossijskoj pravovoj akademii [Bulletin of the Russian legal Academy], 2019, № 3, pp. 31–36. (In Russ.) Servec'kij І.V. Teorіya principіv rozshukovogo prava: monografіya [The theory of investigative principles of law: monograph]. Kiev, 2007, 310 p. (In Russ.) Sereda G. Zakonnіst' operativno-rozshukovoї dіyal'nostі yak meta ta zavdannya prokurors'kogo naglyadu [Legality of operational search activity as the purpose and tasks of Prosecutor's supervision]. Vіsnik Nacіonal'noї akademії prokuraturi Ukraїni [Bulletin of The national Academy of public Prosecutor's office], 2009, № 4, pp. 11–16. (In Russ.)